← All Perspectives
Perspectives · Right Approach

Rabbit, Hunter or Assassin?

Two people can own the same portfolio, start on the same day, and end up miles apart. The difference is what they do next.

Jeremy Sim7 min read

Here's something that surprises a lot of people. Two friends put money into the same portfolio on the same day. Five years later, one of them has a lot more than the other.

Same portfolio. Same start date. Same market. So where does the difference come from? Everything they did in between. And it turns out there isn't actually that much you can do.

In 30 seconds
  • A diversified portfolio is built to grow. What you do while you're in it decides how much of that growth you keep.
  • You only ever have three buttons: do nothing, sell, or buy more.
  • Press them by plan, not feeling. In our example, that was worth S$22,974.
The book

Where this idea comes from

It started with a book that's stuck with me: The Art of Execution by Lee Freeman-Shor, a London fund manager. He gave some of the world's best stock pickers up to $150 million each to run.

The rule: invest only in your ten best ideas. He tracked them for about seven years, across more than 1,800 investments.

The best ideas of some of the world's top stock pickers

Share of their investments that actually made money

49%
Made money. Slightly worse than a coin flip.
51%
Lost money, even though each one was a "best idea"
Working. 100% − 49% of ideas that made money = 51% that didn't.
Source: Lee Freeman-Shor, The Art of Execution (Harriman House, 2015). 45 investors, about 1,866 investments, 2006–2013.

Think about that. These are professionals, picking their very best ideas.

They were right less than half the time.

Honestly, that's one reason I don't build client portfolios around picking stocks. If the best get it right half the time, I'd rather own the whole haystack: a diversified portfolio of thousands of companies, built to compound over the long run.

But here's the part that applies to everyone. Many of those investors still made money, because of what they did after investing. That lesson works for every portfolio.

The three buttons

Once the portfolio is built, you only have three buttons

Here's how I see it. Once the right portfolio is in place, the hard part, choosing what to own, is done. What's left is riding the cycles: up, down, and sometimes nowhere for a while. Through all of it, you only have three choices.

Do nothingSellBuy more

That's it. What changes is when you press them, and why.

Three buttons, two situations, five types of investor

Freeman-Shor's five types, and what each one does with a diversified portfolio

When markets are falling
When markets are rising
Do nothing
The RabbitHolds on, but freezes
The ConnoisseurLets it keep compounding
Sell
The AssassinSells after the fall
The RaiderCashes out early
Buy more
The HunterKeeps buying, rebalances
Keeps topping up as planned
Adapted from Lee Freeman-Shor, The Art of Execution.

Here's the twist. Freeman-Shor was studying stock pickers. With a diversified portfolio, some of the verdicts flip. Let me show you.

The five investors

When markets are falling

Your portfolio is down 20%. The headlines are grim. Here's how each of them reacts.

The RabbitHalf right

"I can't even look at it."

Frozen like a rabbit in the headlights. The Rabbit doesn't sell, which is good, but stops investing, leaves cash idle and stops opening statements.

The catch: holding on is right. Freezing misses the stretch when your money buys the most.

The AssassinCostly here

"Down 20%? I'm out."

The Assassin sells once losses hit a set line, often 20% to 33% in the book. For single stocks, that makes sense.

Why it backfires here: broad markets have historically recovered from every major fall, though some took years. Selling near the bottom doesn't cut the loss. It locks it in.

The HunterBuilt for this

"It's on sale? I'll keep buying."

The Hunter keeps investing, puts spare cash to work in planned steps (more on this later) and rebalances.

Why it works: the same money buys more when prices are down, and all of it recovers with the market.

With a diversified portfolio, the fall isn't the danger. Pressing sell during the fall is.

When markets are rising

Now you're up 20%, 30%. Two instincts kick in.

The RaiderCostly here

"Up 20%? Lock it in!"

The Raider cashes out to "lock in" the gain, planning to get back in later. Freeman-Shor found it one of the most common habits.

The catch: every time you cash out, you reset the compounding clock, and "later" often costs more.

The ConnoisseurBuilt for this

"Let it age like a fine wine."

The Connoisseur lets it keep compounding, rebalancing if one part grows too big, but never cashing out just because.

Why it works: big up days tend to arrive without warning. You only get them if you're still in.

So who should you try to be?

Be The Hunter when markets fall, and The Connoisseur when they rise.

When it fallsKeep investing. Put spare cash to work in planned steps. Rebalance.
When it risesStay in. Let it compound. Rebalance if one part grows too big.

That's the combination a diversified portfolio rewards, because it keeps you invested and adding through the whole cycle.

Quick check · Which one are you?

1. Your portfolio is down 20%. Your first instinct?

2. It's up 30%. Your first instinct?

The story

Two investors, one portfolio, two endings

Let me make this real. Imagine two friends, Daniel and Hui Min.

  • Each has S$110,000
  • Each puts S$100,000 into the same diversified global portfolio, on the same day
  • Each keeps S$10,000 aside in cash

Over five years, the market goes up, down, nowhere for over a year, then up again. A pretty normal cycle, really.

Hui Min planned on day one: stay invested, and if the market falls 25% from its high, put in her S$10,000. Daniel had no plan. He did what felt sensible at each moment.

One market, two investors

An illustrative five-year market path. The portfolio starts at 100 and ends at 140.

Going nowhere80100120140StartYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 51234
1Daniel, the Raider. Market up 20%. He sells half to "lock in" the gain.
2Daniel, the Assassin. Market 20% below its high. He sells the rest.
3Hui Min, the Hunter. Market 25% below its high. Her plan says go, so she adds S$10,000.
4Daniel waits for it to feel safe. He sits out the sideways year and buys back at the old high.
Hypothetical example for illustration only. Not based on any real portfolio, fund or person. Ignores dividends, fees, taxes and currency.

Neither of them did anything crazy. Every one of Daniel's moves felt reasonable at the time. Here's how it adds up.

After five years, from the same S$110,000

$154,359
Hui Min: had a plan and followed it
$131,385
Daniel: reacted to each move
See the full working
Hui Min. $100,000 × (140 ÷ 100) = $140,000. Her $10,000 added at 97.5: $10,000 × (140 ÷ 97.5) = $14,359. Total: $140,000 + $14,359 = $154,359
Daniel, step 1. Sells half at 120: $50,000 × (120 ÷ 100) = $60,000
Daniel, step 2. Sells the other half at 104: $50,000 × (104 ÷ 100) = $52,000
Daniel, step 4. $60,000 + $52,000 + his $10,000 aside = $122,000, back in at 130: $122,000 × (140 ÷ 130) = $131,385
Gap. $154,359 − $131,385 = $22,974
Returns. Hui Min: $154,359 ÷ $110,000 = 1.403, up 40.3%. Daniel: $131,385 ÷ $110,000 = 1.194, up 19.4%
Hypothetical example for illustration only. Past performance is not indicative of future returns.
S$22,974The difference. Same portfolio, same five years, same starting money.

The market rose 40%. Hui Min got the market's result. Daniel got about half, from the same portfolio. He just pressed the wrong buttons at the wrong times.

The portfolio was the same. The investor wasn't.
The big picture

Your portfolio does the heavy lifting

This is how I think about it with clients. Building the right portfolio is my job: diversified across countries and sectors, built to compound over time. After that, the portfolio does the heavy lifting.

Your job is simpler, but not always easier: don't get in its way.

A portfolio can't compound while it's sitting on the sidelines.

And by the way, doing nothing isn't the same as being a Rabbit. Staying put because your plan says "ride through the ups and downs" is a decision. It just looks quiet.

My approach

Being a Hunter, the planned way

So how do you "buy more" in a downturn without guessing the bottom? With strategic capital deployment.

The idea is simple. Keep some excess funds aside and decide in advance how to deploy them if markets fall, in tranches. For example, one third for every 5% to 10% drop in your portfolio or the market.

S$30,000 of excess funds, deployed in three tranches

One third for every 10% fall from the market's high, then the market recovers to where it started.

Market down 10%Level 90Deploy S$10,000Worth $11,111 on recovery
Market down 20%Level 80Deploy S$10,000Worth $12,500 on recovery
Market down 30%Level 70Deploy S$10,000Worth $14,286 on recovery
$37,897
In tranches, once the market recovers
$33,333
All S$30,000 in at the first 10% dip
See the full working
Bought 10% down. $10,000 × (100 ÷ 90) = $11,111
Bought 20% down. $10,000 × (100 ÷ 80) = $12,500
Bought 30% down. $10,000 × (100 ÷ 70) = $14,286
In tranches. $11,111 + $12,500 + $14,286 = $37,897, a gain of $7,897, or $7,897 ÷ $30,000 = 26.3%
All in at the first dip. $30,000 × (100 ÷ 90) = $33,333, a gain of $3,333, or $3,333 ÷ $30,000 = 11.1%
Hypothetical example for illustration only. Ignores dividends, fees, taxes and currency. Past performance is not indicative of future returns.

Hui Min did a simple version of this with one trigger. Tranches are the more disciplined way.

I'll be straight with you about the trade-off. If the market dips 10% and bounces straight back, two thirds stays in cash. That's okay. You still bought at a discount, and the rest is ready for the next downturn. It's not a matter of if, but when.

You don't need to find the bottom. You just need a plan for the way down.

How much to keep aside, the tranche sizes and the triggers depend on you. That's honestly a big part of what I do. Not predicting the market, because nobody can, but building the right portfolio, working out a plan like this with each client before it's needed, and being there through every cycle to help them press the right buttons.

The takeaway

The right portfolio takes care of the compounding. Your job is to keep your finger off the wrong buttons.

The investors, figures and market path in the "two investors" and "deploying in tranches" examples are hypothetical and for illustration only. Book figures are from Lee Freeman-Shor, The Art of Execution (Harriman House, 2015). Past performance is not indicative of future returns. This article is for general information only and does not constitute financial advice.

Know someone who'd find this useful? Share on WhatsApp

Have a question about your own situation?

Get in touch →